We asked five AI assistants the same 80 questions voters are asking about the 2026 U.S. midterms, from Senate toss-ups to candidates' stances on tariffs, on five consecutive days. Then we read every answer, counted which candidates each assistant names, and traced every source behind them. The assistants often disagree on who is ahead and change their calls overnight, Google's AI Mode mostly declines to say, Gemini all but stopped calling races after the first day, and three in five citations come from traditional newsrooms.
Asked the 26 race questions on each of five days, Perplexity named a favorite or a toss-up in 128 of 130 answers and never refused. It called 71 for Democrats and 29 for Republicans, against 58 and 25 for ChatGPT and 19 and 6 for Gemini. When the assistants explicitly recommend candidates, Democrats make up 72% of Perplexity's picks and 71% of both ChatGPT's and Gemini's.
Asked who is favored in 16 Senate and 10 governor races on each of the five days, ChatGPT and Perplexity named a favorite or called a toss-up in 121 and 128 of 130 answers. Google AI Mode did so in 27, between three and seven a day. In most other cases it listed the candidates and told users to consult news outlets, and 23 times it declined outright. In Maine it said such predictions "cannot be verified."
On 28 September Gemini named a favorite or a toss-up in 22 of 26 race questions. On 29 September it did so in 6, and on 30 September in none. It still answered every question, but 24 of its 26 race answers that day did not name a single candidate: they pointed users to Ballotpedia, pollsters, local news or official election sites instead. On 1 October it named a favorite in three races, all of them Democrats (Mark Warner in Virginia, Roy Cooper in North Carolina, Jon Ossoff in Georgia), and declined outright in ten, up from five the day before. On 2 October it called four: Roy Cooper again, Juliana Stratton in Illinois and Josh Shapiro for governor of Pennsylvania, plus a Republican for governor of Kansas without naming one. Its average answer shrank from 1,450 characters on the first day to between 760 and 830 on every day since, and James Talarico, named in 11 of its answers on the first day, appeared in 3, 4, 3 and 3.
ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity disagreed on whether anyone has the edge in six of the 11 battleground Senate races on 28 September, in ten on 29 September, in all eleven on 30 September, in nine on 1 October and in ten on 2 October, largely because Gemini stopped calling races. Verdicts moved from day to day too: over the five days, 14 of ChatGPT's 26 race questions got more than one verdict, and 12 of Perplexity's. In Alaska, ChatGPT went from a toss-up to naming Republican Dan Sullivan the favorite and back to a toss-up, where it stayed, while Perplexity went from Democrat Mary Peltola to a toss-up and back to Peltola for the last three days. In Texas, Perplexity said Democrat James Talarico is favored on the first two days, called it a toss-up on the next two and named Talarico again on 2 October; ChatGPT called it a toss-up all five times.
Three in five citations (10,640 of 18,031) point to news outlets and independent journalism. When we could classify the page type, 70.2% of cited pages were news articles. Explainers and guides made up 11.6%, and landing pages 5.7%.
The ten most-cited domains account for 20.7% of all citations, and the top 25 for 37.8%. The Washington Post leads with 545 citations, followed by Ballotpedia (524), The New York Times (492) and NBC News (411).
AI leans on rankings and aggregators for "who is favored" questions: Ballotpedia, 270toWin, Cook Political Report and The Hill's Senate rankings. Their race ratings travel straight into AI answers.
Among organizations named inside the answers, pollster Siena appeared in 2.6% of answers, Marist in 2.2% and YouGov in 2.0%. The political group named most often was MAGA Inc., with 59 mentions and a 5.4% share of organizational mentions.
For all the campaign content on social platforms, AI assistants rarely cite it: 310 citations in total. Facebook (149) and YouTube (125) lead. Reddit was cited six times and X three times.
Sites run by campaigns, PACs and advocacy organizations drew 546 citations over five days. AI describes candidates through what reporters and trackers write about them, and much of it is recent: heavily cited pages include Reuters, The Washington Post and The 19th stories published in September 2026.
Every question was phrased neutrally and asked of each assistant once a day, on five consecutive days from 28 September to 2 October. The share of Democratic mentions shows how the named candidates split by party within each category (Republican share is the remainder; independents excluded).
| Category | Qs | Example question | Most-named candidates | Dem. share |
|---|
ChatGPT writes the longest answers and names the most candidates per answer. Perplexity names the widest range of people and calls almost every race. Google AI Mode makes few race calls, Gemini's answers halved in length after the first day, and by the third it answered election questions mostly with links to other sources, and Google AI Overviews did not appear at all for 258 of 400 questions.
Answers to "Who are the candidates in the 2026 [state] Senate race and who is favored to win?" asked on five consecutive days, 28 September to 2 October. Where an assistant reached the same verdict on all five days, one label covers them; where it changed its call, each verdict is shown with the days it held. Hover a label for the sentence it rests on.
| Race | ChatGPT | Gemini | Perplexity | Google AI Mode | AI Overviews |
|---|
Three measures, each split by party, over all five days. On plain mentions all five assistants are close to even. The gap opens when they judge. Every assistant recommends more Democrats than Republicans, and every assistant that calls races calls more of them for Democrats. Perplexity leans furthest among the assistants that answer consistently. Google AI Mode mostly declines to judge at all, and from the second day on Gemini joined it.
Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews recommend few candidates at all, so their shares rest on small numbers.
How to read this. A tilt in these numbers is not proof of partisan bias. Many of 2026's most competitive Senate seats are held by Republicans, so questions about flips, underdogs and momentum naturally surface Democratic challengers. Several governor races in the sample, such as New York, California and Pennsylvania, have a Democrat whom all the answering assistants describe as a clear favorite. The assistants repeat what polls, forecasters and news coverage report. The differences between assistants asked identical questions on the same days, and within one assistant from one day to the next, are the finding.
Number of answers (out of 1,741 with text, over five days) that name each candidate, across all five assistants. Office-holders not on the 2026 ballot, such as Donald Trump and J.D. Vance, are excluded.
The first three candidates of the relevant party that appear in each answer, in order, on each of the five days. Order of appearance is a signal of prominence, not an endorsement, and a name can appear as context (for example, the seat a candidate is running for).
| Question | Day | ChatGPT | Gemini | Perplexity | Google AI Mode |
|---|
Every campaign, PAC and advocacy site in the study, taken together, was cited about as often as The New York Times alone.
Race-overview pages win. The single most-cited URL is CBS News' list of 12 key Senate races, ahead of Cook Political Report's Senate race ratings and NBC News' midterms hub. Most of the rest are "races to watch" lists and race ratings, the format that answers "who is favored" in one place.
| # | Page | Type | Citations |
|---|
Your own website is a minor input. What AI says about your candidate is built from news coverage, Ballotpedia profiles and race ratings. Keep those accurate and current, and give reporters clear, quotable policy positions.
Race explainers and "races to watch" lists are being read by machines as much as by people. Clear dates, structured candidate lists and plain statements of who is favored make coverage easier for AI to cite correctly.
Nonpartisan guides compete for a small number of slots dominated by large publishers and Ballotpedia. Earning mentions in coverage from those sources is the most direct route into AI answers.
More voters now ask an AI assistant who is running and who is ahead before they read a single article. The five assistants we tested gave different answers to the same question, changed their answers from one day to the next, and two of them mostly declined to say who is ahead. What they say is built almost entirely from news coverage, race ratings and Ballotpedia, not from campaigns. Anyone who wants to be described accurately by AI has to be described accurately in the sources AI reads.
Source: Scorra and Organicly, "Who's Winning the Midterms? Depends Which AI You Ask", October 2026. 2,000 answers from ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews to 80 questions (US, English), collected 28 September – 2 October 2026.
This report was prepared by Scorra, which tracks what AI assistants say when people ask them questions, and Organicly (organicly.agency), an organic growth agency.
Scorra measures how ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI describe your brand, every day.
Run a free scan